Discover

When I first booted up the new Top Spin game, I was genuinely excited to dive back into virtual tennis. The series has been dormant for years, and as someone who's spent countless hours with sports simulations, I had high expectations. That initial excitement, however, was quickly tempered when I started to explore what the game had to offer beyond its primary mode. The options outside of MyCareer are, to put it bluntly, extremely barebones. Now, I get it—this is effectively a fresh launch for the Top Spin series after a long hiatus. The developers likely focused their resources on getting the core gameplay and MyCareer mode right, which they absolutely did. The tennis mechanics feel fantastic, responsive, and deeply engaging. But here's the thing: as I spent more time with the game, I couldn't help but feel a sense of disappointment creeping in. When you look at other major sports titles, like NBA 2K, which boasts a wealth of modes including MyTeam, MyLeague, and various online competitions, Top Spin's offering feels sparse by comparison. It's not just about quantity; it's about longevity and replay value. I remember firing up NBA 2K24 and being overwhelmed by the sheer number of things to do, both online and offline. In Top Spin, once you step outside of MyCareer, you're essentially left with local play that's limited to single and doubles exhibition games, and the Top Spin Academy tutorials.

Let me talk about the local play for a moment. As someone who occasionally has friends over for gaming sessions, I was hoping for more variety. Exhibition matches are fun for a quick game or two, but they lack the depth and progression that keep players coming back. There's no tournament mode, no career-style progression for local multiplayer, and no custom league options. I found myself thinking back to other tennis games I've played, like the older Virtua Tennis titles, which often included mini-games and world tour elements that added layers of enjoyment. In Top Spin, it feels like the local play was almost an afterthought. I get that online features are a huge focus in modern gaming, but not everyone wants to play competitively online all the time. Sometimes, you just want to relax on the couch with a friend and work through a tournament bracket. The absence of these features is noticeable, and it detracts from what could have been a more well-rounded package.

Then there's the Top Spin Academy, narrated by tennis legend John McEnroe. I have to say, McEnroe's voice adds a touch of authenticity and charm to the tutorials. His commentary is engaging, and he breaks down the mechanics in a way that's easy to understand. For newcomers to the series or to tennis games in general, this is a great starting point. I went through the Academy myself, and it provided a solid overview of how to play, covering everything from basic shots to advanced strategies. But here's my issue: once you've run through it once, there's little reason to return. The tutorials don't adapt to your skill level or offer advanced challenges for seasoned players. I completed the Academy in about an hour, and since then, I haven't felt the need to revisit it. Compare that to something like the training modes in FIFA or Madden, which often include dynamic drills that change based on your performance and can be replayed for continuous improvement. Top Spin Academy feels static, and while it's a nice addition, it doesn't offer much value after that initial run-through. I'd estimate that 90% of players will only engage with it once, which is a missed opportunity for ongoing engagement.

From a broader industry perspective, this highlights a common challenge in sports game development. Publishers are under immense pressure to deliver polished experiences at launch, especially when reviving a beloved franchise. In the case of Top Spin, the team at 2K Czech—or whoever is handling development now—clearly prioritized the MyCareer mode and core gameplay. And to be fair, they nailed those aspects. MyCareer is immersive, with a satisfying progression system that sees your custom player rise through the ranks. The gameplay itself is some of the best I've experienced in a tennis sim, with realistic ball physics and responsive controls that reward skill and timing. But in focusing so heavily on one area, other modes have suffered. I've been playing sports games for over 15 years, and I've seen how franchises evolve. NBA 2K, for instance, didn't become the behemoth it is today overnight. It built up its mode variety over multiple iterations. However, in today's competitive landscape, players expect a certain level of content at launch. When a game like Top Spin launches with limited options, it risks losing players to other titles that offer more bang for their buck.

I also can't ignore the financial aspect. Sports games are big business, with annual releases generating billions in revenue globally. For example, the NBA 2K series reportedly brings in over $1 billion in microtransactions alone each year. That kind of success allows for extensive post-launch support and mode diversification. Top Spin, as a reboot, doesn't have that established player base or revenue stream yet. So, from a business standpoint, it makes sense to focus on core features first. But as a player, it's frustrating. I paid $59.99 for this game, and while I don't regret the purchase because the core gameplay is superb, I do wish there was more to do. I've probably sunk about 40 hours into MyCareer, but after that, my playtime has dropped off significantly. I'd love to see post-launch updates that add new modes, like online tournaments or a more robust local play option. The foundation is there; it just needs to be built upon.

In my experience, the most successful sports games are those that cater to different types of players. Some people love deep career modes, others thrive in competitive online play, and many enjoy casual local multiplayer. Top Spin currently excels in one area but falls short in others. I recall playing Top Spin 4 back in 2011, which had a more diverse set of modes, including party-style mini-games and a comprehensive online circuit. It's a shame that some of those elements didn't carry over into this new installment. That said, I'm hopeful for the future. If the developers take player feedback into account—and I've seen plenty of discussions online echoing my sentiments—we could see significant improvements in future updates or sequels. For now, though, Top Spin is a game with incredible potential that hasn't fully been realized. It's a solid 7.5 out of 10 for me, with points deducted for the lack of mode variety. If you're a hardcore tennis fan or someone who loves deep career modes, you'll find a lot to love here. But if you're looking for a game with endless replayability across multiple modes, you might want to wait and see how it evolves.